7 responses to “American Idol New Judges”

1. 

   Sharon

   September 17, 2012 at 4:02 pm

   Dede: As you know I respect your opinion and read your blogs a lot. I think this panel is a train wreck waiting to happen. Mariah is probably only one that knows music well enough to judge others. Keith is a nice guy and can sing Country so he is a good addition but he won’t fulfill expectations that producers want. Randy is also a really nice guy but should have left AI as a judge years ago. Why they are keeping him I don’t understand. he really never gave constructive criticism as he should have. None of these judges will do what Adam Lambert could have done for the panel. He’s been in their shoes and contestants can relate to him. He’s a classically trained singer and has sang all genres except Country but problem could sing that if he chose to do it. He would be fair but honest and actually give them advice they can use. None of the above judges will do that. Also isn’t it odd that the demographics are so titled on the panel. I always thought the panel should portray the demographics of that country. The Voice has 1 Blk and 3 White judges. Same with XF. So why would AI do this. It’s makes no sense. I’d like to hear your opinion on this. thanks

   Loading…

   Reply
   1. 

      De De Tillman

      September 17, 2012 at 5:52 pm

      Hey honey, Gee I miss you so much! In my blog, I think Adam Lambert, Aretha Franklin etc would have been more qualified to be a judge, That Nicki person OMG what a freaking joke… Randy is a “Yes Man” to me, he is a joke as well…

      I don’t care for Paula due to a personal reson however, she wwas the best as far as I am concern.. Simon was in and out but, he gave his honest opinion…

      They considered Carrie Underwood at one point, I think she dis not accept it due to the fact she is much too busy… Carrie could not handle the R&B/Soul week on Idol and that brings me back to Adam, He NAILED every Genre they gave him.

      You, Beverly, La Tray and I pretty much agree and repect each other, You are so right this season is a TRAIN WREAK…

      Love You So Much
      De De

      Loading…

      Reply
      1. 

         Sharon

         September 17, 2012 at 6:01 pm

         Thanks so much honey I miss you too.

         Loading…
      2. 

         De De Tillman

         September 17, 2012 at 6:23 pm

         Hi Sharon, I will watch this nightmare if you and Beverly will watch it…It’s gone to hell as far as I am concern (American Idol)

         Love U Muah
         De De

         Loading…
      3. 

         Sharon

         September 17, 2012 at 6:26 pm

         I just can’t watch the nightmare. Don’t think many Glamberts will tune in but may watch few min just to see how NM acts. lol

         Loading…
      4. 

         De De Tillman

         September 17, 2012 at 6:31 pm

         I don’t blame you at all, as a matter of fact I stopped watching Idol when Adam did not win, I followed Casey James ONLY after that, I do not know who the others were. I have don blogs on what they report but, I am finished with Idol for good… Nicki is a freaking joke to me, I just do not understand Idol anymore…

         So, as we speak, Let’s spread the word, NOT TO SUPPORT AMERICAN IDOL… okay?

         Love U
         De De

         Loading…
      5. 

         De De Tillman

         September 17, 2012 at 6:36 pm

         Hey Sharon, I just updated the blog wishing the contestants & judges good luck and that I will not be watching or supporthing the show…As a matter of fact I will not be doing any blogs about the show regardless as to who wins///

         Love Love and Hugs
         Your Friend
         De De

         Loading…